Jamie likes to watch crime shows on television and she jokes that it prepares her to spot crimes happening around her. A few years ago she spotted a rolled-up piece of carpet someone had dumped on a grassy hillside on the way to church. What if there was a dead body rolled up in the carpet? That's just the kind of thing you'd see in a television police drama, after all. So for weeks, as we drove past that rolled-up carpet, she'd tell the kids she thought there might be a dead body in it. She asked them to go look many times - and they were very reluctant even though she offered them money! But what if you really suspected someone - say, a beloved family member - of being a murderer? That's the story in Alfred Hitchcock's 1943 classic "Shadow of a Doubt."
"Shadow of a Doubt" was nominated for an Academy Award and is considered to be one of Hitchcock's finest films (he said it was his favorite among his American films). According to biographer Patrick McGilligan, this is what Hitchcock called a "run for cover" film, like "North by Northwest," another of my favorites. The initial script was written by Thornton Wilder who wrote Our Town, lending not only an "American" flavor but also a touch of morbidity. But Hitchcock's scripts always went through multiple rewrites, almost always by him and his wife, Alma.
As I've been gradually watching Hitchcock's movies I'm always impressed by how skillfully he creates and heightens suspense through the story, and he sometimes adds subtle humor at the same time. In this one, young Charlie's father (Henry Travers, who later played Clarence in "It's a Wonderful Life") shares a keen interest in crime stories with his neighbor, Herbie (Hume Cronyn in his film debut). The two constantly discuss ways to commit the perfect crime - usually in front of Uncle Charlie - which is kind of funny and adds suspense since that's what he is suspected of doing. And when you watch it notice the chilling effect of the ominous black smoke that billows out of the train when Uncle Charlie arrives.
As for the suspicious rolled-up carpet, it turned out there was no body inside. But I hear it was quite funny watching the boys cautiously creep up to it, saying "you look," "no, you look."